The below is our view, not legal, tax or accounting advice and should not be relied upon as such.
The longstanding flat spending limit for Cycle to Work looks appealingly fair and unambiguous. In practice, however, it turns away higher earners, risks ruling out cargo and adapted bikes and puts the risk around leavers in the wrong place. Jamie Milroy explains where Cycle to Work spending limits generally sit, why a limit linked to employee salaries works better, and how to set one.
Introduction
The setting of a spending limit for employees, or at least the formulation of a general policy on how employee orders will be considered for approval, is a key ingredient for a successful Cycle to Work scheme over the long term. It helps an employer manage its downside risk around leavers and provides clarity to employees over what they can realistically get through the scheme operated at their company. Both are highly desirable.
From our perspective, and certainly what we encourage for most employers, the best Cycle to Work spending limit is a dynamic one: a percentage of each employee's monthly base salary, typically 100%. On that basis, an employee on £30,000 a year has a limit of £2,500, and one on £60,000 has a limit of £5,000 (which is not to say they have to spend all of it).
As Cycle to Work evolves from a simple tax relief into a meaningful employee benefit, proactive employers are increasingly questioning whether the fixed caps they advertise, typically between £2,000 and £5,000, are still fit for purpose. Increasingly, the answer is no.
Across the nearly 1,000 schemes we have set up for clients, we consistently see employers using dynamic, salary-linked limits get almost twice as much scheme engagement as those using flat caps, along with materially higher National Insurance savings and, perhaps surprisingly, lower financial risk.
What's wrong with a flat Cycle to Work cap?
A flat cap gives every employee the same limit. This sounds fair, but employees' pay, and the bikes they need (and indeed want), are not the same. That causes four problems:
- Lower earners are disappointed. You might assume this group benefits most from a flat limit. But a flat limit suggests everyone can spend up to that figure. In practice, employees on more modest salaries often can't, because salary sacrifice can't take their pay below the National Living Wage. Orders are rejected, and the experience is poor, especially when the reasoning is explained in deflating detail.
- Higher earners are frustrated. Senior staff, whose earnings would comfortably support a bike above the limit, feel unfairly constrained, even patronised, which dampens uptake and goodwill.
- Cargo and family e-bikes are ruled out. Our platform gives us sight of almost every bike on the market, and quality family and cargo e-bikes start at around £4,000 and often cost more than £7,000. A flat limit of £2,000 to £5,000 stops many parents from getting a bike that suits their circumstances, nudging them back into the car and undermining the scheme's sustainability goals exactly where the scheme could have the biggest impact.
- Adapted cycles are ruled out. Basic adapted cycles cost £500 to £1,500, but the specialist trikes, handcycles and electric-assisted models that employees with mobility needs typically require for commuting routinely cost £3,000 to £7,000 or more. A flat limit at these levels can bar disabled employees from the benefit altogether. That is an inclusivity issue, and potentially a reasonable adjustments issue under the Equality Act 2010 [1].
For these reasons, our view overall is that fixed limits tend to do more harm than good, especially when considered against the alternative. They constrain the value of Cycle to Work as a benefit, and they expose the employer to financial complications that are not always obvious (more on this below).
For employers looking to the scheme for National Insurance savings, our data shows that lower fixed limits significantly curtail total savings compared with an equivalent dynamic policy.
How much can I spend on Cycle to Work?
What we see working best is a dynamic spending limit, equal to a percentage of an employee's monthly base salary. The percentage is typically 100%, but it can be lower.
With a dynamic limit, employees' spending capacity is directly linked to their earning capacity and moves with it. It intrinsically keeps affordability at the heart of the scheme, limiting employees from spending beyond their means. It also improves take-up and makes it more inclusive, while also protecting the employer financially.
High earners do not have their spending curtailed unnecessarily. For lower earners, the policy largely eliminates the disappointment of having orders rejected because of the minimum wage, as the next section shows.
It also adds no work for whoever approves orders: each order is already checked against the employee's pay for the minimum wage, so the same check can easily be extended to cover the limit.
How does the minimum wage affect a dynamic spending limit?
A salary sacrifice arrangement must not reduce an employee’s cash earnings below the minimum wage [2]. For workers aged 21 and over, that is the National Living Wage, which is currently £12.71 an hour from 1 April 2026 and will rise to £13.21 an hour from 1 April 2027 [3][4]. Lower rates apply to workers under 21 and some apprentices. Under a flat cap, that is what turns lower earners’ otherwise compliant orders away.
With a limit of 100% of monthly base salary and a 12-month hire, the most an employee gives up each month is one twelfth of their pay. To stay above the minimum wage after that, their monthly pay needs to be at least 12/11 of the minimum wage for their hours, or about 9% above it.
For the most common full-time hours, that means an employee’s spending is limited only by their dynamic spending limit, not by the minimum wage, from these salaries:
| Hours per week | Salary needed now (from 1 April 2026) | Salary needed from 1 April 2027 |
|---|
| 35 | £2,103 a month (£25,235 a year) | £2,186 a month (£26,228 a year) |
| 37.5 | £2,253 a month (£27,038 a year) | £2,342 a month (£28,101 a year) |
| 40 | £2,403 a month (£28,840 a year) | £2,498 a month (£29,975 a year) |
Because a 12-month hire starting now will run past 1 April 2027, it is worth checking new orders against the April 2027 figures. Employees close to the current thresholds may need to reduce their sacrifice after that date, unless their own pay rises too.
For context, HESA’s latest Graduate Outcomes figures put the median salary of UK graduates in full-time work, around 15 months after graduating, at £30,000 [5]. That is above all three thresholds at both rates, though only just at 40 hours a week from April 2027, so a typical graduate a year or so into their career can use their full limit.
Below those salaries, an employee can still use the scheme, but for less, depending on how far their pay is above the minimum wage. Employees paid at or very close to the minimum wage can pay from their take-home pay instead, without the tax saving. Lower-cost options, such as e-bike subscriptions and bike share, also have smaller monthly payments, which further helps to remove the minimum wage as a constraint.
How does a flat cap put risk on lower earners?
There is a less-discussed but important consequence of flat caps. Under a salary-linked policy, the employer's maximum exposure on any one employee is a single month's base pay. If an employee leaves part-way through their agreement, the outstanding balance is collected from their remaining pay, including the final payslip, and one month's pay can normally be recovered that way. A flat cap severs this link, and in doing so, inverts the risk profile in a way most employers don't intend.
Consider two employees under a £5,000 flat cap:
- Employee A earns £35,000, about £2,917 a month. A £5,000 outstanding balance is roughly 1.7 months of their pay.
- Employee B earns £120,000, about £10,000 a month. A £5,000 balance is just half a month of their pay.
If either leaves part-way through, the balance is almost certainly recoverable in full from Employee B's final pay, but very unlikely to be fully recoverable from Employee A's. The employer ends up concentrating its recovery risk on its lower earners, who are the least able to absorb a clawback, while leaving the recovery headroom of its higher earners unused. That is the opposite of how most employers would design a benefit from scratch.
A dynamic limit resolves this automatically: every employee, whatever their seniority, stays within the same recoverable envelope of one month's pay.
How do you set a dynamic spending limit?
In practice, moving to a dynamic limit is straightforward. The policy wording typically reads along the lines of: "The maximum spending limit available under the scheme is equal to one month of the employee's gross base salary at the point of application."
Most of our clients land on 100% of monthly base salary as the cleanest, most defensible figure, although some opt for 80% or 90% to build in a small buffer. The limit is shown to employees when they apply, so they know where they stand from the start.
The right percentage also depends on notice periods. The longer an employee's notice, the more pay there typically is to recover a balance from if they leave. Some employers go substantially below 100% where employees are on one or two weeks' notice. Where three-month notice periods are common, as at many professional services firms, we routinely see limits of 1.5 times monthly salary and over.
For employees whose pay varies, such as shift or variable-hours staff, a sensible starting point is 75% of average gross monthly pay over the previous three months. The lower multiple protects the employer if those earnings fall, while still giving those employees access to the scheme.
Whatever limit you choose, we would always recommend building in some flexibility too, and setting out in the policy how discretion will be used for orders above the limit, such as an adapted cycle or a bike that is only just over. There's nothing more frustrating for an employee than not being able to get their ideal bike because it's a mere £50 over the limit.
If you are setting up a scheme from scratch, the spending limit belongs in the scheme policy. Our guide to the business case for a Cycle to Work scheme [link to follow] includes it in the plan for launch, with a template you can adapt.
Should employers switch to a dynamic spending limit?
Adopting a salary-linked spending limit lets your scheme be used with greater flexibility, responsibility and inclusivity. Employers using dynamic limits see almost twice as much scheme engagement as those using flat caps, greater National Insurance savings and a financial risk profile that is both lower and more evenly spread across the workforce.
Beyond the financial benefit to employees, it means a healthier, happier and greener team, with outstanding balances more reliably recoverable from final pay should the need arise.
If you're currently operating a flat cap and would like to discuss moving to a dynamic limit, we'd encourage you to speak with your scheme provider about how it would work for your team.
About the author
Jamie Milroy is Founder and CEO of DASH, the FCA-authorised Cycle to Work platform used by organisations including the Financial Times, Deliveroo, Lovable and several NHS trusts. A chartered accountant (ACA, ICAEW) by training, formerly of PwC, he leads DASH's work on Cycle to Work, salary sacrifice and the tax treatment of employee benefits and remuneration. He is a member of Reward Strategy's Partner 75, recognising excellence within the pay and reward industry, speaks regularly on Cycle to Work and employee benefits, and has been quoted in outlets including The Times and City AM.